Heavy Metals in Supplements: What You Need to Know
Compartir
Dum de dum dum. That impending doom feeling. That’s what most of us feel when we are confronted with the idea of ingesting heavy metals. The only thing worse are the PFAS (Per- or poly Fluorine Alkyl Substances) known as forever chemicals. And they are bad news for about the same reason. Nothing in nature breaks them down, and they tend to just accumulate in the body until there is so much it causes all kinds of health problems, including Man’s most dreaded disease.
So what are heavy metals anyway? Well, that depends on who you ask. In chemistry, it means any metal that has 5 times the density of water, all conditions of temperature and pressure consistent. This definition includes even the beneficial minerals.
That is not what we mean, however, when we voice concern over their health hazards.
What we mean is any metallic element that has a relatively high density and is toxic at low concentrations. It mainly includes Mercury, Cadmium, Arsenic, Chromium, Tellurium, Nickel, and Lead. It can also include Selenium, Zinc, and Copper in specific forms and in higher concentrations. And although not commonly mentioned, Aluminum would fit that definition as well.
Heavy metals are natural constituents of the Earth’s crust and are present in varying concentrations everywhere on the planet. But some things man has done and is doing have concentrated these substances, so toxicity has become an issue.

The main activities in question are present and former mining activities, foundries and smelters, and a very broad category called diffuse sources.
Diffuse sources are called that because they come from all over and wind up in the air, water, and dirt, and are notoriously difficult to control, and they wind up in our bodies because they get into the food supply.
Some of these sources include:
- Piping
- Combustion products
- Traffic fumes
- Lead Paint which isn’t made anymore, but continues to leach from former paint jobs
- Copper, Chromium, and Arsenic-treated lumber
- Batteries- Zinc, Lead, and old Mercury batteries
- Cadmium in phosphate fertilizers
- Mercury from switches, thermometers, and dentistry
- Certain forms of copper and tin from paints and coatings used on ship hulls to prevent algae and barnacle growth
- Copper in biocides
- Waste products resulting from metal polishing
- Electroplating
- Leather Tanning
- Concrete production
- Fireworks
- Rubber Tires and Brake pads that wear out and give off particulates (Unfortunately, living so close to Santa Monica Blvd, I can attest to this by the black sticky dust that invades my apartment every day.)
- Galvanized (zinc) or chromium-coated steel that weathers in the elements
- Copper roofs that oxidize over time
- And relatively recently, the concentrated animal farming operations known as CAFOs or Factory Farms, which are toxic in so many terrible ways.
- And that brings me to the primary focus of heavy metals to us at Herbal Roots. We obviously want to bring you herbal products that have zero heavy metals. And we have been very diligent in our sourcing to be as successful at that as humanly possible.
Considering the fact that even totally remote areas with virtually no people present still test for some level of heavy metals in the soil because they are just naturally occurring, and being that we also we live in a biosphere called Earth and when the systems of water, air and soil get contaminated, it circulates the whole planet, we are doing incredibly well at getting close to zero in our endeavor. It has taken us years to do it.
Let’s go over some numbers. There are 7 heavy metals that the US EPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency) considers a priority to monitor and control for public safety. They are Arsenic, Cadmium, Chromium, Copper, Nickel, Lead, and Zinc.
There are ranges of safety set instead of firm thresholds because different environmental situations can increase or decrease the toxicity level of the same amount of contaminant, and there are different forms of the contaminants which vary the toxicity.

Here are the ranges of allowed amounts set by the US EPA. These are the amounts allowed in the soil. Commercial soil and residential soil have slightly different allowed levels, but all are within this range:
- Arsenic (As) 1- 1.1 ppm (parts per million)
- Cadmium (Cd) .48 - 2.5 ppm
- Lead (Pb) 63 - 200 ppm
- Nickel (Ni) 30 - 50 ppm
- Copper (Cu) 27 - 50 ppm
- Chromium (Cr) 30 ppm
- Zinc (Zn) 23,000 - 30,000 ppm
The FDA only monitors 4 heavy metals. Lead, Arsenic, Cadmium, and Mercury. The FDA does not clearly explain what levels of these substances are allowed. This is because Zero is obviously the ideal, but that would eliminate most food, including vegetables. There wouldn’t be anything to eat. So it is a work in progress with ongoing studies. The FDA calls it its Closer to Zero Initiative. The goal is to have action levels as opposed to stating what levels are allowed. And the action isn’t even laid down as far as I can understand, but it is geared toward trying to remedy the situation.
The only completed work I could find were numbers on lead in things babies and young children under 2 would eat.
The “safety margins” that the FDA uses work like this. They decide by studies observing what minimum level of contamination causes something bad, and then they put a factor of 10 in effect to make sure the level is “safe”, OKing 10 times less than that amount.
Current action and guidance levels for Lead:
- Fruits, vegetables, yogurts, custards, and meat mixtures - .01 ppm.
- Dry infant cereals and single-ingredient root vegetables (like carrots and sweet potatoes) - .02 ppm.
- Bottled Water - .005 ppm. (Matches EPA standards.)
-
Candy .1ppm
Arsenic - measures only inorganic forms - carbon-arsenic compounds are stable and do not react in the body, and just get filtered out in the urine. This is the arsenic mostly found in fish, shellfish, and seaweed. But Arsenic combined with non-carbon elements like iron or sulfur are not as stable and they don’t stay intact in the body, and they mimic phosphate. This is betrayal on a chemical level. The body tries to use it to make energy, but it doesn’t make ATP, and so the cell starves. It also damages DNA and causes rapid cell death.
- Apple Juice - .001ppm
- Infant Rice Cereal - .1ppm
California Prop 65 has a different way of looking at the concentration of heavy metals and other contaminants that could cause cancer or reproductive harm. It is not based on a straight concentration present, but the amount that would be ingested in each serving daily. It is hard to compare the EPA and FDA numbers to the California Prop 65 numbers. One is concentration depicted in ppm and Prop 65 is expressed in micrograms.

To compare the two, you would have to do the following conversion:
Allowed ppm = Prop 65 micrograms/serving size in grams.
Now in California, like the FDA, they don’t give the number found to be safe - they factor in a safety margin. The FDA, as I mentioned, uses a 10th of the number found to not cause any bad effects just to be sure, but California goes all out and uses a factor of 1000! And dramatically calls this level a “Safe Harbor” amount. How touching. Except for one thing. It doesn’t leave anyone anything to eat!
Even vegetables in the supermarket have more heavy metals than that, and meats and seafood have even more. So how does that get handled? Well, there are exceptions made that exempt foods from having to use the Prop 65 label. It’s all worded very confusingly, and you have to apply for it, but that is the end result. Foods are, for the most part, exempted.
Here are the Prop 65 numbers:
- Lead - 0.5 micrograms per day
- Inorganic Arsenic - 10 micrograms per day
- Cadmium - 4.1 micrograms per day
- Mercury - .3 micrograms per day.
So let’s say the serving size of a product is 12.5 grams. That is equivalent to a tablespoon of sugar. So for lead you take the .05 prop 65 # and divide it by 12.5 grams. This gives you .004 ppm.
This number can be compared to the ppm units of the EPA and the ppb (parts per billion) of the FDA. I converted all the numbers I listed to all ppm so all could be easily compared.
And herbs, although I consider them a food, Prop 65 doesn’t. So it is a double standard. But the diligent work of the sisters (the ones who own Herbal Roots) has overcome! Drum Roll please: They have gotten the levels so clean that the prop 65 label is not needed on Herbal Roots supplements! Hooray!!! That means there is less of a trace in our herbs than in the food in the supermarket.
We love to bring you the best!!! And just so you know, our effective eight mushroom blend and the Reishi and Cordyceps taken regularly will help you usher the heavy metals you inevitably collect right out your system through your bowels and bladder. So happy healthing.

*This article is intended for informational purposes. The statements above have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.