Glass Bottles vs. Plastic Bottles for Supplements
Compartir
It is said that the things to consider when choosing between these is stability, cost, logistics, and environmental impact of using one or the other, but I think it comes down to what is better for your health and the health of the planet. What do you think?
Instinctively, I think we all know what is the clear choice, but economics always rears its ugly head to cloud the issue. Hopefully, I can show you a few things to uncloud the issue and make it at least clear, if not crystal clear.
First, there is the most important thing. Which keeps the product more preserved, making its potency last without use of chemical preservatives?
The two things that reduce freshness the most are oxygen and water vapor in the air.
Moisture causes tablets to break down. It causes probiotics to lose viable organism counts. It causes protein powders to oxidize and clump. And it causes water-loving substances like magnesium, collagen, and creatine, and most importantly to us, herbal powders, to absorb water from the air and lose potency.

So how does glass measure up in preventing this? In a peer-reviewed study published in Science Direct, WVTR- Water Vapor Transmission Rates were measured across glass and the most common plastics for bottled supplements, PET and HDPE.
The results:
-
Glass transmitted .07mg of moisture per day.
-
HDPE transmitted 0.8mg of moisture per day
-
PET transmitted 9.9mg of moisture per day
That means glass was more than 140 times better than HDPE and over 11 times better than PET.
For oxygen, the same study showed that glass outperformed both plastics in stopping oxygen transmission, with PET performing much better than HDPE.
So, PET didn’t do so well with water, but was much better with holding back oxygen, and HDPE was better with water, but not so good with oxygen.
Glass held back both water and oxygen much better than either plastic.
The next thing that reduces potency is exposure to light.
Phytochemicals in herbs like chlorophyll, flavonoids, and polyphenols, when exposed to light, degrade rapidly and can become biochemically inactive.
The solution to that is to darken the glass or plastic so light gets blocked.
Amber glass blocks more than 90% to 99% of harmful ultraviolet (UV) and blue light wavelengths (typically up to 450 nanometers). The amber color is baked directly into the material using iron, sulfur, and carbon, meaning the UV-filtering properties never degrade or wear off.

Amber plastic, made with color additives, can also block a high percentage of UV light depending on the thickness of the plastic and the pigment concentration. Lower quality, thinner plastics, and /or the uneven distribution of pigment can allow fluctuation of light transmission.
The gold standard in this regard is considered to be amber glass.
This is, of course, influenced by the fact of its other property of being completely chemically inert. No matter how long the contents are stored in glass, the glass will not interact with it or leach chemicals into it. This makes it ideal, even for volatile essential oils or reactive phytochemicals in herbs, as well as chemical reagents and pharmaceutical preparations.
Amber plastic can let in certain gases, oxygen, and organic solvents. Over time, plastics can leach chemicals into the contents or absorb essential oils and active ingredients out of the contents, trapping it in the plastic container.
The next thing to consider is what happens to the containers if they are not recycled. Many times in the past, we thought we were recycling, but it was just a drill, and there was no actual recycling.
Glass is made of natural silica, like sand. If it gets into the environment, it just wears away back into sand. When it washes up on shore, it is called sea glass, and people feel lucky to find it and use it in jewelry and arts and crafts or add it to their shell collection, etc.
Plastic, on the other hand, makes a mess. It gets melted by the sun and gets into our food supply because it winds up ingested by fish and wildlife. Plastic mimics fat and is not bad-tasting; it can even make things extra creamy and satisfying, but it sure doesn’t metabolize like fat, and it causes slow, gruesome deaths to millions of wild animals, according to earth.org. And it isn’t helping the health of us humans either. More and more are discovering the role of microplastics in health catastrophes. Physiological clogs are painful and hard to detect and get rid of, and that is what happens with plastic.
Recycling programs, fortunately, are improving, so more and more things are getting recycled. PET plastic, Polyethylene Terephthalate, code #1 plastic can be processed into fleece, polyester clothing fibers, carpet, and new containers.

HDPE, High-Density Polyethylene #2 Plastic can be turned into plastic lumber, outdoor furniture, recycling bins, and new bottles.
But not all places have recycling programs operating, and only about 5% of plastics thrown into recycling bins actually get made into these things. The rest goes into landfills or gets incinerated, releasing toxic chemicals into the air or is washed out into the ocean, according to Greenpeace, Ocean Conservancy, and many others.
Yikes! So why on earth would anybody opt for packaging in anything but glass?
Well, it is heavier and costs more to ship glass. And glass can break if it is not protected and handled right. And maybe they don’t know the actual facts about plastic recycling.
At Herbal Roots, we don’t cut corners. We use thick amber glass and metal lids, and we protect that glass in a recyclable cardboard box. And we don’t charge you for shipping. We want what is best for you and our planet.


