What is CCOF and how does this relate to USDA Organic?

Someone holding up a young basil plant in soil

CCOF stands for California Certified Organic Farmers. It is the main USDA (US Department of Agriculture) accredited organic certifying agency and trade association.

An Organic Certifying Agency makes sure that all the rules are strictly followed and that an establishment qualifies to call its crops or livestock organic. It’s like this: the USDA sets the rules and standards in their NOP- National Organic Program, but it doesn’t go out to a farm to see what they are doing. A farmer has to hire an agency to come out and certify that they qualify to use the USDA Organic seal. And then it has at least one inspection a year to keep its qualification. And the CCOF can do surprise inspections any time during the year to confirm compliance.

A Trade association is a nonprofit organization that is formed and funded by businesses operating in a specific industry or trade. It acts as a collective “industry voice” to set standards and provide networking and educational opportunities for its members. It advocates shared interests and influences public policy.

For instance, recently, a preservative called Apeel was approved by the USDA to be used on Organic Foods. This was very alarming, especially because 90% of this preservative is listed as inert ingredients without any disclosure as to what the actual ingredients are. Only Citric acid was listed, and the rest, a mystery, a trade secret.

Well, the CCOF raised the adamant rejection of this preservative forced upon Organic Farmers and the public, and now “Organipeel” is no more. Thank You, Thank You! Unfortunately, “Edipeel” is still being used on conventional vegetables.

Farmer's Market stand whith fresh vegetables in baskets.

This is probably why the CCOF is the most popular certifying agency used. They also have international certifications for exporting to Canada, Japan, or the EU, which helps the farmer sell globally. They have additional programs like Certified Transitional designations as well. This rewards farmers for their effort and expense because they are doing all the practices of an Organic farmer but haven’t qualified for organic because of the 3 years of clean land requirement. The CCOF also mentors the farmer during those years.

The USDA Organic seal means the following:

  • No Synthetic Chemicals

Crops are grown without prohibited synthetic fertilizers, pesticides, or herbicides, and the land they are grown in has to have been free of these chemicals for at least 3 years prior to being qualified for certification.

  • No GMOs

Genetically modified organisms (GMOs) are completely prohibited in organic production.

  • Strict Animal Welfare

Organic livestock are raised in living conditions that accommodate their natural behaviors, are given access to the outdoors, and are fed 100% Organic with no growth hormones or antibiotics.

  • Environmentally Friendly 

Farming practices must be sustainable. That means they have to maintain or improve soil and water quality, minimize erosion, and avoid soil contamination.

  • Supply Chain Integrity

The certification process traces the product from the field to the fork. It ensures that processors, handlers, and brokers also adhere to strict organic handling and packaging requirements.

The rules are a little different for packaged goods.

  • 100% Organic Label, all ingredients must be certified organic, excluding water and salt. 

The USDA Organic seal can be used.

  • Organic means there has to be at least 95% organic ingredients by weight, and the remaining ingredients must be approved non-agricultural substances from the National List of Allowed and Prohibited Substances, which is laid out as part of the NOP. For example, things like citric acid or baking soda could be allowed.

The USDA Organic seal can be used on these products.

  • Made with Organic Ingredients means that there are at least 70% organic ingredients, and those ingredients are labeled organic in the ingredients list on the back of the package, either by the word organic or an asterisk, which indicates the organic ingredients. There is a 3-ingredient limit of what can be claimed as organic on the front of the package to stem any deception that it is all organic.

The USDA Organic seal may not be used.

Below 70%, no claim to be organic can be listed anywhere on the package except in the actual ingredients list.

I don’t know about you, but I never realized so much went into actual package labeling. I, for one, was taught by my mother to always ignore anything on a label as hype and go right for the ingredients list. I now see why that was good advice.

I never knew that companies tried to be deceptive about being organic by listing a lot of organic ingredients present in minuscule amounts on the front of the package.

Someone holding a crate of mixed veggies.

I do know that it happens in food supplements that the formula is supposed to be echinacea, for instance, which has a distinct flavor and action on the tongue, but you could put the whole bottle in your mouth all at once and still not taste it or feel its effect at all. There is so much filler and not so much “main” ingredient. That’s the main reason the Herbal Roots Company was founded. No fillers in Herbal Roots products, ever, just the main ingredient.

Now, if the CCOF is so good, why do we have about 80 other companies also accredited by the USDA to do that job?

Well, the reasons listed are lower cost, less paperwork, better customer support, or different philosophies, including regional considerations. What does a California guy know about growing blueberries in New Hampshire, for instance?

Alternative options allow a grower to tailor certification to their specific operational needs. A grower that just sells his stuff at a roadstand and has a full-time job as well does not have the same needs as a farmer who is trying to provide fruit to the entire planet.

You may be familiar with some of these other agencies. Here are some other commonly seen authorizing agencies:

Baystate Organic Certifiers based in Massachusetts. They are known for being more friendly and supportive with dedicated customer service and quick communication lines to clear up any confusions about what substances are compliant with the NOP and which ones aren’t. They don’t have hidden costs and are generally very pleasant to deal with. Can service any state.

Oregon Tilth (OTCO).  Highly respected and established. Has a national footprint with deep expertise in agriculture. It is a teaching organization and is not for profit. Tilth actually means the condition of the soil and its suitability to growing and nurturing crops.

Quality Assurance International (QAI) Massive Global certifier. Excellent for large-scale handling, processing, and global supply chains.

Rows of green plants in a field.

Nature's International Certification Services (NICS).  Very helpful to farmers navigating the complexities of making the transition over to Organic Farming. It handles crops, wild crops, livestock, and processing/handling operations and transitional certification.

I used to think, before I did all this research, that each of these certifying agencies had their own criteria for what was Organic. I had never even heard of the NOP, National Organic Program, which is the standard. I thought the problem with USDA controlling Organic was a weakened criteria. It isn’t. 

Watchdog associations like OrganicEye and The National Organic Coalition (NOC) are always on the lookout for loopholes and deceptive wording that weaken enforcement of the NOP laws. And apparently they are very busy. We have them to thank for keeping our food supply safe. Supporting and following those organizations is probably a good idea.

It is my hope that knowing these things will help you to read labels more clearly and help you navigate in your quest to have the most optimum nutrition and avoid toxins for you and your family, and even your community's best health.

Get your Certified Organic supplements today!

Certified Organic Pure Herbal Supplements
Organic herbal supplements to buy

 

 

Text about Herbal Roots author Rosalie Roder with her photo in a red shirt.

*This article is intended for informational purposes. The statements above have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.
Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.